Owl: Juan Linz Correct? US Democracy Dead?

Civil Society, Corruption, Cultural Intelligence, Government, Idiocy, Ineptitude
Who?  Who?
Who? Who?

IF the Late Juan Linz Called It Right, American Democracy May Collapse Soon

“In a merciful twist of fate, Juan Linz did not quite live to see his prophecy of the demise of American democracy borne out. Linz, the Spanish political scientist who died last week, argued that the presidential system, with its separate elections for legislature and chief executive, was inherently unstable. In a famous 1990 essay, Linz observed, “All such systems are based on dual democratic legitimacy: No democratic principle exists to resolve disputes between the executive and the legislature about which of the two actually represents the will of the people.” Presidential systems veered ultimately toward collapse everywhere they were tried, as legislators and executives vied for supremacy. There was only one notable exception: the United States of America.”

Is there a way to settle the shut-down and debt-ceiling dispute? The answer is in this especially frightening conclusion to this article:

“How to settle this dispute? Here is where Linz’s analysis rings chillingly true: “There is no democratic principle on the basis of which it can be resolved, and the mechanisms the Constitution might provide are likely to prove too complicated and aridly legalistic to be of much force in the eyes of the electorate.” This is a fight with no rules. The power struggle will be resolved as a pure contest of willpower. In our Founders’ defense, it’s hard to design any political system strong enough to withstand a party as ideologically radical and epistemically closed as the contemporary GOP. (Its proximate casus belli—forestalling the onset of universal health insurance—is alien to every other major conservative party in the industrialized world.) The tea-party insurgents turn out to be right that the Obama era has seen a fundamental challenge to the constitutional order of American government. They were wrong about who was waging it.”

This is frightening for various reasons, but in the course of waging a brutal, maybe unprecedented “pure contest of willpower,” a dictator, to avoid a possible greater evil, may emerge and take control to end the crisis.

More:

The Shutdown Prophet