Berto Jongman: New studies: ‘Conspiracy theorists’ sane; government dupes crazy, hostile + Cabal / Conspiracy Meta-RECAP

Cultural Intelligence
Berto Jongman
Berto Jongman

New studies: ‘Conspiracy theorists’ sane; government dupes crazy, hostile

Dr. Kevin Barrett

PressTV, 13 July 2013

Recent studies by psychologists and social scientists in the US and UK suggest that contrary to mainstream media stereotypes, those labeled “conspiracy theorists” appear to be saner than those who accept the official versions of contested events.

In short, the new study by Wood and Douglas suggests that the negative stereotype of the conspiracy theorist – a hostile fanatic wedded to the truth of his own fringe theory – accurately describes the people who defend the official account of 9/11, not those who dispute it.

Recent studies by psychologists and social scientists in the US and UK suggest that contrary to mainstream media stereotypes, those labeled “conspiracy theorists” appear to be saner than those who accept the official versions of contested events.

The most recent study was published on July 8th by psychologists Michael J. Wood and Karen M. Douglas of the University of Kent (UK). Entitled “What about Building 7? A social psychological study of online discussion of 9/11 conspiracy theories,” the study compared “conspiracist” (pro-conspiracy theory) and “conventionalist” (anti-conspiracy) comments at news websites.

Complete article below the line.

The authors were surprised to discover that it is now more conventional to leave so-called conspiracist comments than conventionalist ones: “Of the 2174 comments collected, 1459 were coded as conspiracist and 715 as conventionalist.” In other words, among people who comment on news articles, those who disbelieve government accounts of such events as 9/11 and the JFK assassination outnumber believers by more than two to one. That means it is the pro-conspiracy commenters who are expressing what is now the conventional wisdom, while the anti-conspiracy commenters are becoming a small, beleaguered minority.

Perhaps because their supposedly mainstream views no longer represent the majority, the anti-conspiracy commenters often displayed anger and hostility: “The research… showed that people who favoured the official account of 9/11 were generally more hostile when trying to persuade their rivals.”

Additionally, it turned out that the anti-conspiracy people were not only hostile, but fanatically attached to their own conspiracy theories as well. According to them, their own theory of 9/11 – a conspiracy theory holding that 19 Arabs, none of whom could fly planes with any proficiency, pulled off the crime of the century under the direction of a guy on dialysis in a cave in Afghanistan – was indisputably true. The so-called conspiracists, on the other hand, did not pretend to have a theory that completely explained the events of 9/11: “For people who think 9/11 was a government conspiracy, the focus is not on promoting a specific rival theory, but in trying to debunk the official account.”

In short, the new study by Wood and Douglas suggests that the negative stereotype of the conspiracy theorist – a hostile fanatic wedded to the truth of his own fringe theory – accurately describes the people who defend the official account of 9/11, not those who dispute it.

Additionally, the study found that so-called conspiracists discuss historical context (such as viewing the JFK assassination as a precedent for 9/11) more than anti-conspiracists. It also found that the so-called conspiracists to not like to be called “conspiracists” or “conspiracy theorists.”

Both of these findings are amplified in the new book Conspiracy Theory in America by political scientist Lance deHaven-Smith, published earlier this year by the University of Texas Press. Professor deHaven-Smith explains why people don’t like being called “conspiracy theorists”: The term was invented and put into wide circulation by the CIA to smear and defame people questioning the JFK assassination! “The CIA’s campaign to popularize the term ‘conspiracy theory’ and make conspiracy belief a target of ridicule and hostility must be credited, unfortunately, with being one of the most successful propaganda initiatives of all time.”

In other words, people who use the terms “conspiracy theory” and “conspiracy theorist” as an insult are doing so as the result of a well-documented, undisputed, historically-real conspiracy by the CIA to cover up the JFK assassination. That campaign, by the way, was completely illegal, and the CIA officers involved were criminals; the CIA is barred from all domestic activities, yet routinely breaks the law to conduct domestic operations ranging from propaganda to assassinations.

DeHaven-Smith also explains why those who doubt official explanations of high crimes are eager to discuss historical context. He points out that a very large number of conspiracy claims have turned out to be true, and that there appear to be strong relationships between many as-yet-unsolved “state crimes against democracy.” An obvious example is the link between the JFK and RFK assassinations, which both paved the way for presidencies that continued the Vietnam War. According to DeHaven-Smith, we should always discuss the “Kennedy assassinations” in the plural, because the two killings appear to have been aspects of the same larger crime.

Psychologist Laurie Manwell of the University of Guelph agrees that the CIA-designed “conspiracy theory” label impedes cognitive function. She points out, in an article published in American Behavioral Scientist (2010), that anti-conspiracy people are unable to think clearly about such apparent state crimes against democracy as 9/11 due to their inability to process information that conflicts with pre-existing belief.

In the same issue of ABS, University of Buffalo professor Steven Hoffman adds that anti-conspiracy people are typically prey to strong “confirmation bias” – that is, they seek out information that confirms their pre-existing beliefs, while using irrational mechanisms (such as the “conspiracy theory” label) to avoid conflicting information.

The extreme irrationality of those who attack “conspiracy theories” has been ably exposed by Communications professors Ginna Husting and Martin Orr of Boise State University. In a 2007 peer-reviewed article entitled “Dangerous Machinery: ‘Conspiracy Theorist’ as a Transpersonal Strategy of Exclusion,” they wrote:

 

“If I call you a conspiracy theorist, it matters little whether you have actually claimed that a conspiracy exists or whether you have simply raised an issue that I would rather avoid… By labeling you, I strategically exclude you from the sphere where public speech, debate, and conflict occur.”


But now, thanks to the internet, people who doubt official stories are no longer excluded from public conversation; the CIA’s 44-year-old campaign to stifle debate using the “conspiracy theory” smear is nearly worn-out. In academic studies, as in comments on news articles, pro-conspiracy voices are now more numerous – and more rational – than anti-conspiracy ones.

No wonder the anti-conspiracy people are sounding more and more like a bunch of hostile, paranoid cranks.

Kevin Barrett
Kevin Barrett

Dr. Kevin Barrett, a Ph.D. Arabist-Islamologist, is one of America’s best-known critics of the War on Terror. Dr. Barrett has appeared many times on Fox, CNN, PBS and other broadcast outlets, and has inspired feature stories and op-eds in the New York Times, the Christian Science Monitor, the Chicago Tribune, and other leading publications. Dr. Barrett has taught at colleges and universities in San Francisco, Paris, and Wisconsin, where he ran for Congress in 2008. He is the co-founder of the Muslim-Christian-Jewish Alliance, and author of the books Truth Jihad: My Epic Struggle Against the 9/11 Big Lie (2007) and Questioning the War on Terror: A Primer for Obama Voters (2009). His website is www.truthjihad.com. More articles by Dr. Kevin Barrett

Phi Beta Iota:  It’s not a conspiracy if there is enough evidence to indict — and there is.

See Also:

2013 Robert Steele: It’s Time for Crisis Mappers to Spin Up Corruption Mappers 2.0 + Corruption RECAP

2013 Robert Steele Reflections on Insanity & Integrity + Reflections RECAP

2013 Robert Steele: Reflections on Lincoln, Principle, Compromise, Autonomous Internet & Citizen Intelligence / Counter-Intelligence 2.0 with Meta-RECAP

2013 Robert Steele: Reflections on Inspectors General

2010 Robert Steele: Reflections on Integrity UPDATED + Integrity RECAP

Benjamin Fulford: Global Chaos, Cabal Crumbling

Berto Jongman: Catholic Church — Dead or Just Comatose? + Catholic / Pedophilia RECAP

Berto Jongman: Col James Steele, USA — Death Squads & Torture from El Salvador to Iraq — One of the “Boys” with Back Door Access to Rumsfeld

Berto Jongman: Data Emergent on Extra-Terrestials + RECAP

Berto Jongman: “Deathbed” Testimony” about UFOs and Area 51 from former CIA Officer + UFO Meta-RECAP

Berto Jongman: Deviant Globalization + Legalized Crime Meta-RECAP

Berto Jongman: If One Man Speaks Truth, What Prevents All Others from Hearing Him?

Berto Jongman: Sandy Hook Reprise — What? + Plus Lack of Truth in USA RECAP

Berto Jongman: Shadow Banking & Tax Loopholes – With Comment by Robert Steele on Integrity & Automated Transaction Payment Tax

Berto Jongman: SSCI Pre-Hearing Q&A — Superb Questions, Cloudy Answers — Robert Steele Answers 6 of 40 Questions Honestly + IC/CIA Health RECAP

Berto Jogman: Testimony on Five Extraterrestial Races, to Mock Congress, After the Boston Bombing, by Hon. Paul Hellyer, former Minister of Defense for Canada

Berto Jongman: YouTube (11:24) Russia Today TV Nails DHS, FBI, and Boston Leaders — Federal, State, & Local Officials Impeachable + Boston Meta-RECAP

Berto Jongman: YouTube 14:17) 2012 Corbett Report on Media Manipulation

Berto Jongman: Video Evidence 9/11 Attack Vehicles Were USG Controlled Drones

Bin Laden Show: Entries 00-90 UPDATED 26 Jan 2013

BREAKING NEWS: US Government Assassinated Martin Luther King (Trial Is Over — 13 Years Ago — But Now People Are Starting To Understand — BEFORE 1 Black Man with a Voice NOW All of Us Who Dissent) + USG Assassination RECAP

Chuck Spinney: Bin Laden, Perpetual War, Total Cost + Perpetual War RECAP

Chuck Spinney: Can USA Move Beyond 9/11 Pathology?

Chuck Spinney: Demonizing Iran, Bankrupting America

Chuck Spinney: From Algeria to Libya –Lessons Not Learned + USG CIA Web of Deceit in Arabia RECAP

CURVEBALL: The Interview + Integrity RECAP

DefDog: 9/11 Refutations Gaining Traction

DefDog: Bruce Hoffman, the US IC, Bin Laden…Many Contradictions

Denis Smajlaj: Rolling Stone Apologizes to Conspiracy Theorists — and Notes US Judges Helping Banks Avoid Accountability Today

Dolphin: 9/11 — Explosive Experts Speak Out

Eagle: Big Lies, Small Minds — An Explanation

G.I. Wilson: Killer Drones, Moral Disengagement, + War Crimes RECAP

Gordon Duff: Mind Control, Lef-Right Myth, Re-Connecting to Reality + Meta-RECAP

Henry Kissinger: “The illegal we do immediately; the unconstitutional takes a little longer.”

Honoring Martin Luther King — With Truth

Iceland Gets It Right: Say NO to Bank Bail-Outs

Jean Lievin & Jon Rappoport: Is Ed Snowden A Stake In Heart of USG-Wall Street Market Rigging? Is an Impeachment Shit-Storm Looming? Will Extratradition of US Bankers Be Demanded?

Jim Clapper: Do I Really Want to Be Here? + Robert Steele’s Simple Guide to Fixing National Intelligence + Intelligence Failure Meta-RECAP 2.0

Jim Fetzer: Can the Ghost of JFK Save Obama, Call Out Papa Bush, & Expose Texas’Treason? + LBJ-Texas-CIA Assassination RECAP

John Maguire: Blowback or Criminal Insanity? Ockham’s Razor Applied

John Steiner: Fukushima Update — Worse, Uglier, Worry More…. + Fukushima & US Nuclear RECAP

Journal: Crazy Conspiracy Memes–Theirs & Ours

Journal: Deep Secrets, Copenhagen World Government, the M-Fund, and the Future

Journal: Five Myths Debunked–Treasury Run by Crooks

Koko: Alternative View Calling for a New World Order Based on Water, Castrated Bankers, and Death Sentence for Politicians Betraying the Public Trust

Marcus Aurelius: US at Permanent “War” + War RECAP

Marcus Aurelius: VIDEO Extreme Prejudice – CIA Whistle Blower [then Congressional staffer] Susan Lindauer PDX 911Truth

Matt Taibbi: GRIFTOPIA – RECAP

Michelle Monk: PROOF of 1400+ ELITE resignations, mass arrests, retirements

Mini-Me: Asian Deep Wealth versus US/EU Illuminati/Nazis

Mini-Me: Boston Casualties Vanish Into Thin Air + Boston/Texas Meta-RECAP

Mini-Me: Clinton, Bush, Obama, Gore, Cheney, Biden All Indictible and Impeachable — the NY Times Story Obscured by Boston Bombs — Meanwhile, FBI Director Past 10 Year Limit + False Flag RECAP

Mini-Me: Former Leader of Guatemala Is Guilty of Genocide Against Mayan Group – US Leaders Should Note….

Mini-Me: From 9/11 to Arab Spring to Iran War — Who, Exactly? + Meta-RECAP

Mini-Me: Fukushima – Japan’s 911 Israel’s Follow-Up to US 911 — Plus Comment on Need for Global Inspector General with Counterintelligence Mandate

Mini-Me: Gay Pedophile Cabal Across the Vatican & Globally-Distributed Archbishops and Cardinals? What do Skull & Bones, the Bohemian Grove, Some Flag Officers, and the Vatican Have in Common? A Culture of Impunity and Betrayal of the Public Trust

Mini-Me: Geithner’s Fingerprints? Tungsten Gold Bar in UK + Meta-RECAP on Financial Fraud

Mini-Me: Germans Suspect Federal Reserve Bank of NY Has Stolen 1536 MetricTonnes of Gold — On Tim Geithner’s Watch

Mini-Me: JFK Assassination Cover-Up Unravels Further + RECAP

Mini-Me: Marine Officer on 9/11 – The Anomalies Continue to Surface

Mini-Me: Murder of 9/11 Author & Former Pilot — and Kids, and Dog

Mini-Me: Myths of US Government Shattered – JFK Assassination by USG Cabal Set to Unravel Along with 9/11 Related Lies and Cover-Ups

Mini-Me: War Crimes as US Strategy, Policy, Operational Campaign, & Centerpiece for Tactics

Mini-Me: WWIII, from Gold Circles, A Whiff of…? + RECAP

Mongoose: 20130309 Added Transcripts for Mrs. Kay Griggs Interviews — “German Disease” Across USMC & US Army Special Operations + Treason RECAP

Mongoose: 9/11 Treason, Plain and Simple? — The Answers — Including Nuclear — Keep Coming to the Surface — Rumsfeld-Cheney Key, But Subordinate to Bush Senior and a Financial Cabal

Mongoose: Is General Patraeus Slated for “Suiciding?” + Meta-RECAP on No Rule of Law in USA

Mongoose: Mea Maxima Culpa – Silence in the House of God + Catholic Perversion RECAP

Mongoose: The bloodhounds of [corrupt] capitalism

Mother Jones: Their Will Be Done — CIA and the Vatican

Paul Craig Roberts: The Libor Scandal In Full Perspective + Meta-RECAP

Penguin: US/UK Perpetuate Soviet False Flag Model + Meta-RECAP

Owl: 33 “Conspiracy Theories” Proven True — Many with Government Betrayal of Public Trust as Central Feature

Owl: FBI Retiree on Neocons, Terrorists, Blurring Lines — and the Mossad Cover Story — Could the US Public be Approaching a Revolutionary Moment?

Owl: Micro-Nuke in Boston, Someone Planting False Evidence? Staged Fireball, Most Injuries Staged? + Meta-RECAP

Owl: NSA Perfect Storm — Time to Clean House — Fire Alexander, Close DNI Down (Restore DCI), Cancel CIA Drone Program (“A Thousand Genocides”), Fund Open Source Agency….

Owl: Pedophilia as “Privilege” and “Pure” — Single Source Page for Glimpse of the Chasm Into Hell — Coast to Shining Satanic Coast – FBI Complicit 1.4

Owl: Strong Indications Colorado “Terrorist” an FBI False Flag UPDATED 28 July 2012

Owl: Why Obama Will Survive Five Scandals, Persist on Syria, & Risk WWIII

Reference: 100 Critical Points About 9/11

Reference: Invisible Empire New World Order DVD + RECAP

Reference: John Brennan’s Opening Statement — Extreme Fluff + CIA Meta-RECAP

Reference: US Secret Intelligence, US Banks, Illicit Gold, Murder of the Global Economy, RECAP

Reform Coalition: “True Cost” Economics & Genuine Progress + True Cost RECAP

Robert Steele: Honoring Martin Luther King RECAP

SchwartzReport: Corporate Cabal Taking Over World Food and Water Supplies — Until the Riots — Will Vigilantes Begin Hunting Down and Killing Monsanto Executives?

SchwartzReport: Religious Treason within US Military

SchwartzReport: Tom Engelhardt — No Longer in Search of Enemies — We Have Created Them and Turned the World Against the USA

Search: China Fake Gold + Fraud RECAP

Search: cost of corruption + Corruption RECAP

Search: slide designs corruption + RECAP

Seven Promises to America–Who Will Do This?

Strong Signals: Truth or Tyrannicide + RECAP

Susan Lindauer: YouTube (9:52) — RT Interview on How Bush and Cheney Both Knew About 9/11 Months Before It Happened

What Presidents Don’t Know About Education Plus RECAP of 6 Star Plus Books Relevant to Creating a Smart Nation with a Strategic Narrative that WORKS

Why Isn’t Wall Street in Jail? + US Fraud RECAP

Winslow Wheeler: ONE COLONEL TELLS THE TRUTH – Major Investigation Called For + Meta-RECAP

Worth a Look: 9/11 Books, DVDs, Videos, and Other

Worth a Look: Book Reviews on General & Specific Corruption 2.0

Worth a Look: New Movie on 9/11 “A Violation of Trust?

Worth A Look: Understanding 9/11 and 9/11 RECAP

Yoda: Pope Acknowledges Corrupt Gay Cabal Across Vatican & Church