Chuck Spinney: Syrian Use of Chemical Weapons? Bullshit. + Syria Regional Meta-RECAP

04 Inter-State Conflict, 05 Civil War, 07 Other Atrocities, 08 Proliferation, Officers Call
Chuck Spinney
Chuck Spinney

Pressure is mounting for the US to become involved in the Syrian civil war.  Advocates of intervention have all sorts of motives.  Once of the most attractive talking points from the perspective of the interventionists is the Syria’s alleged use of chemical weapons on its own people.  This short and well focused essay addresses that allegation …. The author is one one of the most seasoned reporters now covering the Middle East.

MAY 20, 2013

Why the Claims of Sarin Gas Don’t Add Up

Syria Has No Reason to Use Chemical Weapons

by PATRICK COCKBURN, Counterpunch

‘I am not afraid of anything except for God and poison gas,” said an Iraqi officer who had fought in the Iran-Iraq war. “It’s like a ghost. You have no defence against it.” Though not a target of poison gas as a member of the army using it, he knew what it did to its victims.

Poison gas is a terrifying weapon. People are still dying in Iran from the effects of ingesting it a quarter of a century ago. It is one of the few weapons to be banned with partial success between its first use on a mass scale in the First World War and again by Saddam Hussein with even greater intensity against Iranians and Kurds in the 1980s.

It is right, therefore, that the alleged attack by the Syrian armed forces using chemical weapons against Saraqeb, a rebel-held town south-west of Aleppo on 29 April, should be carefully investigated. Doctors told the BBC’s Ian Pannell that after an artillery bombardment they treated eight people with breathing problems, some of whom were vomiting and others who had constricted pupils.

One woman named Maryam Khatib later died. Her son Mohammed said: “It was a horrible, suffocating smell. You couldn’t breathe at all. You’d feel like you were dead. I couldn’t see anything for three or four days.” Videos taken by local people show a helicopter dropping an object which appears to leave a trail of white vapour.

My experience of trying to report allegations of the deployment or use of such weapons over the years makes me cautious.Local people, including local doctors, are often sincerely convinced that some exotic weapon has been used against them, but they may not have past experience of either conventional or chemical attack.

For instance, doctors in Fallujah west of Baghdad suspect that non-conventional weapons must have been used against the city when it was stormed by US forces in November 2004. This might explain why so many malformed babies have been born since. It is impossible not to sympathise or suppress a feeling of rage over the sufferings of these people.

But, in blaming non-conventional weapons, people may underestimate what conventional munitions can do. In two weeks’ fighting in Fallujah in 2004, US marine artillery units fired an average of 379 high-explosive 155mm shells a day into this small city. In addition, American jets flying overhead dropped 318 bombs and, together with helicopters, fired 391 rockets and missiles.

At the time, the Iraqi government of Iyad Allawi made the unlikely claim that just 200 buildings in Fallujah had been destroyed or damaged. A recently published book, The Endgame: The Inside Story of the Struggle for Iraq from George W Bush to Barack Obama by Michael Gordon and Bernard Trainor, from which the above figures are taken, reveals that the US marines “estimated that out of about 50,000 residences in the city, their operations had destroyed between 7,000 and 10,000, as well as 60 mosques”. Perhaps this vastly excessive use of firepower is sufficient explanation for the appalling birth defects.

Allegations about the use of poison gas in Syria are made under the shadow of the notoriously false claims about Saddam Hussein’s possession of weapons of mass destruction made to justify the Iraq war. Not surprisingly, this has made the public everywhere in the world dubious about stories about the possession or use of WMD being used to hoodwink them into supporting another war.

Of course, it is much against the interests of the Syrian government to use chemical weapons because this might provoke foreign military intervention. 

The Syrian army has no need to use it as a terror weapon because artillery, aerial bombardment and death squads are quite enough to frighten people into taking flight. There are already 1.5 million refugees outside the country.

Journalists bear a large measure of responsibility for giving credence to the stories peddled by Iraqi defectors, intelligence services and government about Saddam’s WMD. In that case, it should have been self-evident that Iraqi defectors with juicy stories, and the opposition parties that promoted them, wanted to tempt the US into military action against Saddam. When it comes to chemical weapons, the Syrian opposition has similar and wholly understandable motives.

As for the credibility of Western government claims about WMD, it is worth recalling that they tolerated Saddam using poison gas on a mass scale. And they did more than just turn a blind eye. Joost Hiltermann, in his book A Poisonous Affair: America, Iraq and the Gassing of Halabja, writes that Western powers “sent repeated signals to Iraq that the regime could continue, and even escalate, chemical weapons use – which it did, with the Halabja attack [when thousands of Kurdish civilians died] as climax”.

PATRICK COCKBURN is the author of Muqtada: Muqtada Al-Sadr, the Shia Revival, and the Struggle for Iraq.

Phi Beta Iota:  The Fallujah Babies (Shocking Images)  will go down in history as one of the unintended but most graphic crimes against humanity resulting from the elective US invasion and occupation of Iraq, an action based on 935 now-documented lies by Dick Cheney and his merry band of neo-conservative traitors.  There is also documentation now in the public domain of British companies being asked to provide checmical weapons to the Syrian Free Army so that a false flag use of these could be blamed on the Assad government.  We pray SecDef keeps his integrity and does not go along — as Colin Powell did — with treason based on lies.  Meanwhile, it is worth mentioning the fact that the USA poisons its own people in a manner far more persistent and insidious than simple chemical weapons..toxins in everything.

See Also:

2010 Robert Steele: Reflections on Integrity UPDATED + Integrity RECAP

4th Media (Wayne Madsen): USA-CIA-Soros-NeoCons vs Russia in Caucasus

Benjamin Fulford: ZIonists Defeated, China and Russia Playing Smart, Western Banking in Panic — $1 Billion Bet on US Stock Market Crashing Soon — Internal War within USG Between DHS and Everyone Else

Berto Jongman: Assad Moving Missiles to Target Tel Aviv?

Berto Jongman: London Review of Books Detailed Report on Everything the CIA and John Brennan do NOT Know About Syrian Rebels, Corrupt Supply Lines, and Operational Effectiveness

Berto Jongman: Robert Fisk: We Might As Well Name Our Newspapers ‘Officials Say’

Berto Jongman: Stronger Signals US Planning False-Flag Chemical Attack in Syria

Berto Jongman: Swedish Analysis of Syria’s Salafi Insurgents

Berto Jongman: Syrian Electronic Army Does Hard Cyber (Kinetic Effect) Attack on Israel — or Russia Being Clever? Or Both?

Berto Jongman: Western-Imperial Violence — Detailed Dismantling of Steven Pinker’s Apologetics

Berto Jongman: YouTube Audio (48:10) Sibel Edmunds On Boston Bombing, CIA, and US Empire — US Buying Russian Okay on Invading Syria with Hands Off on Caucasus?

Chuck Spinney & Philip Giraldi: The Poisonous (Treasonous?) Influence of the Neo-Cons…Why Isn’t the FBI Going After Them?

Chuck Spinney: Cancer of Careerism – Final Word on Colin Powell’s Moral Suicide

Chuck Spinney: End Time of Tribulation for Israel, the Fake State

Chuck Spinney: From Palestine to Syria to Jordan — The True Cost of Western Ignorance & Arrogance

Chuck Spinney: Hezbollah’s Moment — Historical Force?

Chuck Spinney: Iraq Army Losing North, Partition Being Discussed

Chuck Spinny: Israel Alone, Declared a Terrorist State by Turkey, USA Fading in Region, China Rising….

Chuck Spinney: Reality Reporting from Syria — USG Has No Idea….

Chuck Spinney: Syria, Regional War, and Turkey — Let the Ethnic Cleansing Begin!

Chuck Spinney: The Real Challenges Facing the Next Secretary of Defense, Robert Steele Comments

Chuck Spinney: The Real Scare in Syria is Not Chemical Weapons But Rather Regional War

David Isenberg: The True Cost (Locally) of Military Strikes Against Iranian Nuclear Targets + Iran Nuclear Meta-RECAP

DefDog: IO Coup — Twitter AP Hoax Blows Up US Stock Market — Syrian Electronic Army (Really?) Claims Responsibility

DefDog: Russian Fleet Enters Mediterranean, Parks at Cyprus

Eagle: Benghazi Testimony Forthcoming – Ambassador Stevens Buying Back Weapons Given to Al Qaeda by State for Libya Take-Down — General Ham Directly Ordered Not to Rescue

Eagle: CIA, Militant Islam, the Chechen Connection — Proxy War on Russia, Trade-Off for Syria?

Eagle: GMO Toxins in 98% Unborn Babies

Eagle: Hagel To Meet Free Syrian Army – Israel/AIPAC Hosting Free Syrian Army in Washington DC on 9 May — New War for USA?

Gordon Duff: Was Syria Nuked?

Graphic: Benghazi Fiasco Master Post with Links to All Posts, Map of DoD Assets Ordered to “Stand Down,” + RECAP Updated 11 May 13

Graphic: Map Syria Iran + Syria-Iran-Rergional RECAP

Graphic: Muslim (Islam) Spread Worldwide

Graphic: Really Simple Guide to Syrian-Centered WWIII Starting Line-Up

Graphic: US Bases (44) Surrounding Iran

Jim Dean: Syria — Deception & Disaster — Time for Truth or Consequences

John Steiner: Genetic Foods – Transparency, Truth, & Trust versus Tyranny, Toxicity, & Theft

Mini-Mi: Benghazi, Syria, Russia, & US Clear Violation of International Laws, Treaties, and Embargos

Mini-Me: Iran Is NOT a Nuclear Threat — Cover for Other Actions

Mini-Me: Obama Approves CIA War on Syria, CIA & Arabs Arming Islamic Militants Instead — But Wait, Could This Be Smoke Related to Benghazi-Based Acts of War on Syria?

Mini-Me: Peeling the Syrian Onion

Mini-Me: Reports Sights France and Turkey In An Assassination Plot On Assad

Mini-Me: Syria & Chemical Weapons — Israel Lies, US Unconvinced, Russia Angry — Cost of US Meddling Rises for All

Mini-Me: Israel Finally Has a Master — China

Neal Rauhauser: Syria, Regional War, The Only Red Line That Matters + Syria Meta-RECAP

Neal Rauhauser: Understanding Syria (Dot Chart & Links to 13 Prior Posts)

NIGHTWATCH: AF Attacks up 70%, Iran Warns Israel

NIGHTWATCH: China Shows Muscle & Gravitas — Syria Shows Staying Power — USA Losing on All Fronts Due to Ignorance and Arrogance

NIGHTWATCH: Fall of Jordan Impact on Israel?

NIGHTWATCH: From 1979 to 2012 – No Improvement in DoD Response to Ambassadors and Embassies in Extremis + EE21 RECAP

NIGHTWATCH: Iran, Syria, WMD — and Bolivia Expels AID for Covert Operations

NIGHTWATCH: Iraq, Destabilized Further by Syria, Update

NIGHTWATCH: Pakistan Nuances Not Understood — Same in Syria

NIGHTWATCH: Syria at Risk — Own the Consequences

NIGHTWATCH: Syria, Bio-Chem, & US Intelligence

NIGHTWATCH: Syria is Now a Regional War — Everyone Else Against US, Israel, and Saudi Arabia

NIGHTWATCH: Syria Rebounding, Rebels Fragmenting

NIGHTWATCH: Syria-Russia Update

Owl: UPDATED Top US War Criminals Named [Synopsis Added]

Owl: Why Obama Will Survive Five Scandals, Persist on Syria, & Risk WWIII

Patrick Meier: US AID Crisis Map of Syria

Penguin: Larry Wilkerson Skeptical About Politicization (aka Fabrication) of Syrian Chemical Weapons Reports

Penguin: Open-Ended Global War on “Terrorism”

Penguin: Saudi Prince Bandar Dead? Syria Waging War on Saudis and CIA?

Phil Giraldi: Who’s Turning Syria’s Civil War Into a Jihad?

Rob Dover: Intelligence Failures in Syria & Algeria — Is Open Source Everything an Alternative? Steele Comments

SchwartzReport: Mercury Poisoning Going Critical

SchwartzReport: Tom Engelhardt — No Longer in Search of Enemies — We Have Created Them and Turned the World Against the USA

Search: libyan tribes map + LIBYA RECAP 22 Aug 11

Shiela Casey: Photographic Essay on False flag theater — Boston bombing involves clearly staged carnage + Boston False Flag Meta-RECAP

Susan Lindauer: IRAQ – The Legacy of Deception and Its Costs

Syria a Satellite of Iran? Nah….

Warren Pollock: Interview with John Xenakis on China and Japan, Syria, Turkey, & Iran, The Next War (Audio)