Steve Aftergood: Scientific Accomplishment vs. Scientific Secrecy

Corruption, Government, Law Enforcement, Military
Steven Aftergood

DALE CORSON AND SCIENTIFIC FREEDOM

Dale R. Corson, a nuclear physicist who died last week, is best remembered as the Cornell University President who peacefully led his campus through the turmoil and upheaval of the Vietnam era.  But he also played an influential role in deliberations over the role of secrecy in scientific research.

Dr. Corson chaired a 1982 committee of the National Academy of Sciences that produced a landmark study entitled “Scientific Communication and National Security,” which became known as the Corson Report.

In sober and measured tones, the Corson Report pushed back against calls for increased secrecy in government-funded science:

“Current proponents of stricter controls advocate a strategy of security through secrecy. In the view of the Panel security by accomplishment may have more to offer as a general national strategy. The long-term security of the United States depends in large part on its economic, technical, scientific, and intellectual vitality, which in turn depends on the vigorous research and development effort that openness helps to nurture…  Controls on scientific communication could adversely affect U.S. research institutions and could be inconsistent with both the utilitarian and philosophical values of an open society.”

President Reagan cited Dr. Corson in National Security Decision Directive 189, “National Policy on the Transfer of Scientific, Technical and Engineering Information,” which seemed to affirm that fundamental research should remain unrestricted to the maximum extent possible.  In fact, however, that directive imperfectly reflected the input of the Corson Report, noted Harold C. Relyea in his book “Silencing Science: National Security Controls and Scientific Communication.”

Still, many of the issues identified by Dr. Corson and his colleagues, and the concerns they expressed, remain current today and have not reached an unequivocal resolution, as evidenced most recently by the latest U.S. government policy on dual use biological research.

Phi Beta Iota:  Secrecy is a pathology.  We are reminded of these two quotes….

Carl Jung:  The maintenance of secrets acts like a psychic poison which alienates the possessor from the community.

James Madison: The advancement and diffusion of knowledge is the only guardian of true liberty.

The “security state” is out of control and totally antithetical to all of the principles embodied in the Constitution of the USA.  Excessive unwarranted secrecy whose primary purpose is the avoidance of accountability, when combined with federalized surveillance via cell phone records of every citizen–all warrantless, naturally–comprises the greatest threat to the future of the USA.