Stephen E. Arnold A Fresh Look at Big Data
May 8, 2013
Next week I am doing an invited talk in
London. My subject is search and Big Data. I will be digging into this notion in this month’s Honk newsletter and adding some business intelligence related comments at an Information Today conference in New York later this month. (I have chopped the number of talks I am giving this year because at my age air travel and the number of 20 somethings at certain programs makes me jumpy.)
I want to highlight one point in my upcoming London talk; namely, the financial challenge which companies face when they embrace Big Data and then want to search the information in the system and search the Big Data system’s outputs.
Click on Image to Enlarge
Notice that precision and recall has not improved significantly over the last 30 years. I anticipate that many search vendors will tell me that their systems deliver excellent precision and recall. I am not convinced. The data which I have reviewed show that over a period of 10 years most systems hit the 80 to 85 percent precision and recall level for content which is about a topic. Content collections composed of scientific, technical, and medical information where the terminology is reasonably constrained can do better. I have seen scores above 90 percent. However, for general collections, precision and recall has not been improving relative to the advances in other disciplines; for example, converting structured data outputs to fancy graphics.
I don’t want to squabble about precision and recall. The main point is that when an organization mashes Big Data with search, two curves must be considered. The first is the complexity curve. The idea is that search is a reasonably difficult system to implement in an effective manner. The addition of a Big Data system adds another complex task. When two complex tasks are undertaken at the same time, the costs go up.
Again I am not interested in identifying a particular Big Data or a particular search system. The main point is that when an organization rushes to embrace a blend of search and Big Data, costs are likely to be an issue.
There are four reasons:
First, the blend of search and Big Data is, in my opinion, new territory for most organizations. Search is “old news” and the cost of implementing a search system can be difficult to control. Even the Google Search Appliance imposes a price tag when deployed across a large corpus. Systems from enterprise giants like Dassault, Hewlett Packard, IBM, and Oracle can be substantial as well. Move these big company solutions in and expect to export fees.
Second, the technologies for search and Big Data are coming at information from two different directions. Search has been predicated on the user crafting a query to unlock whatever is in the index. Big Data is assumed to be too voluminous for anyone to “know” what’s in the content. The Big Data system discovers, reveals, shows, or performs some other function to find out what’s in the content.
Third, the computational processes for whacking away at Big Data can be resource intensive. The assumption or assertion that a system can process “all” or “everything” may be unfounded. Attempts to crunch Big Data may fail due to resource constraints or budgets.
Fourth, the fancy math which is easy to reference can be quite difficult to implement in a hybridized system. The reason is that multiple calculations exceed the computational capacity available for a task. Algorithms can be optimized which yields some benefits, but data scientists want to apply more sophisticated processes. As a result, the demand for computational resources in some situations continues to grow. At the same time, the volume of data to be processed grows as well. The result is that decisions have to be made to deliver “good enough” results. Usable outputs are better than no outputs. This problem is not fully appreciated until decisions of consequence must be based on hybridized systems. The phrase “I didn’t understand that” signals the onset of understanding the difference between marketing promises and actual system deliverables.
How many of those in my audience will agree with me? Darned few. My hunch is that most of those attending the conference will be looking to use “Big Data” as a way to generate revenue. I also think that only a handful of people will appreciate the computational challenges which hybridized systems can present.
Stephen E Arnold, May 8, 2013 Phi Beta Iota: There are many severe analytic corruptions in the total concept of “big data.” Most “big data” is like swiss cheese (reminiscent of NGA’s crummy Third World 1:50 combat chart data, still today), the data is driven by Industrial Era factors, and that data is simply not worth the money it takes to process especially when processing blind and processing mush. The human factor continues to be repressed at just the time when it should be coming to the fore. “Transformation” in the 21st Century is not going to come from technology as much as from an enhanced role for properly educated and totally connected humans able to operate in all languages and acquire “just right, just enough, just in time” data from OTHER HUMANS, while leveraging HUMAN-CENTRIC technologies. As usual, the US complex has it upside down and inside out, and is ignoring, among many other vital elements, whole systems analytics, time-based analytics, and true cost economics. A tiny example: big data on “the economy” is stupid — it only covers the one fifth that is traditional “legal” and regulated money. It does not cover System D dollars, barter and time dollars, and well as other forms of compensation. See Also: 20 Sep 2012 Franklin & Marshall College: Internet Technology and the Transformation of the Human 2013 From Information Pathologies to Organizational Intelligence — Why Predictive Analytics on Industrial Era Data is Fraud, Waste, & Abuse 2013 Robert Steele Foreword to NATO Book on Public Intelligence for Public Health 2013 Robert Steele in HighGainBlog on Open and Secret Intelligence 2013 Robert Steele: Reflections on Inspectors General 2013 Robert Steele: Reflections on Lincoln, Principle, Compromise, Autonomous Internet & Citizen Intelligence / Counter-Intelligence 2.0 with Meta-RECAP 2012 Ishmael Jones (P) on The Human Factor 2012 PREPRINT: The Craft of Intelligence 3.4 2012 Reality Sandwich: The Open Source Everything Manifesto 2012 Robert Steele Answers PhD Student Questions 2012 Robert Steele: Addressing the Seven Sins of Foreign Policy — Why Defense, Not State, Is the Linch Pin for Global Engagement 2012 Robert Steele: Practical Reflections on UN Intelligence + UN RECAP 2012 Robert Steele: Reflections on Data as the New Oil BUT No One Is Serious About Holistic Analytics, True Cost Economics, Machine or Man-Machine Translation, or M4IS2 2012 Robert Steele: Reflections on the US Military — Redirection Essential — and a Prerequisite to Creating a 450-Ship Navy, a Long-Haul Air Force, and an Air-Liftable Army + Sanity RECAP 2012 Robert Steele: The Human Factor & The Human Environment: Concepts & Doctrine? Implications for Human & Open Source Intelligence 2.0 2012 Robert Steele: The Human Factor & The Human Environment: Contextual Trust for Sources & Methods 2012 Thomas Briggs on The Human Factor 2012 U.S. Naval Power in the 21st Century: 450-Ship Navy, <24 Hours to Anywhere, Peace from the Sea — Full Text Online 2011: Inteligencia Empresarial y Estrategia Competitiva en Mercados Internacional – Contexto y Desafio [Commercial Intelligence and Competitive Strategy in International Markets – Context and Challenge] 2011 Robert Steele: Global Trends 2030 – Gaps + RECAP 2011 Thinking About Revolution in the USA and Elsewhere (Full Text Online for Google Translate) 2010 M4IS2 Presentacion por Sur America (ANEPE Chile) — 2010 M4IS2 Briefing for South America 2010: OPINION–America’s Cyber Scam 2010 Julian Harston “Intelligence Assessment and Risk Analysis in Peacekeeping and Peace Support Operations – A Necessity” 2010 Reference: 5 Lessons From Outgoing Microsoft Software Architect Ray Ozzie 2008: Creating a Smart Nation (Full Text Online for Google Translate) 2008 Open Source Intelligence (Strategic) 2.0 2008 Rebalancing the Instruments of National Power (Full Text Online for Google Translate) 2008 The Substance of Governance 2006 Robert Steele: Reinventing Intelligence 2004 Simmons (US) to Schoomaker (US) Concern of Army Mis-Definition of Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) as a Category of Information Instead of a Transformational Discipline in its Own Right 2004 Simmons (US) & Schoomaker (US) Hearing on Army Transformation Remarks on Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) 2003 Information Peacekeeping & the Future of Intelligence – The United Nations, Smart Mobs, & the Seven Tribes (Full Text Online for Google Translate) 2003: Peacekeeping Intelligence Leadership Digest 1.0 (Full Text Online for Google Translate) 2002 Pinkham (US) Citizen Advocacy in the Information Age 2000 Sandman (US) Applied Human Intellect: Interpreting the Data Bits 1998 Hughes (US) Foreign Broadcast Information Service (FBIS) 1995-1998: Transition and Transformation 1995 Private Enterprise Intelligence – Its Potential Contribution to National Security (Full Text Online for Google Translate) AMERICA: Y UR PEEPS B SO DUM? Ignorance and courage in the age of Lady Gaga Anthony Judge: Beware of Legality, Accountability, Marketability, Security! Be where the Four Hoarsemen of the Apocalypse are not? Anthony Judge: Cyborgs, Legaborgs, Finaborgs, Mediborgs Meet the extraterrestrials – them is us Anthony Judge: Dynamic Transformation of Static Reporting of Global Processes Anthony Judge: Eightfold Configuration of Nested Cycles of Cognitive Transformations: Meta-pattern of connectivity through a hypersphere? Anthony Judge: Eliciting a Universe of Meaning Anthony Judge: Sensing a Dynamic Pattern of Transformations Anthony Judge: The Cognitive Glass Ceiling — Enabling Questions, Challenged Audiences — Psychic Numbing and the Need for a Transformation of HOW We Think Anthony Judge: Transforming and Interweaving the Ways of Being Stoned — Imagination, Promise, Rocks, Memorials, Petrification Arabia Rising: Understanding Transformations & Revolutions in the Middle East Berto Jongman: 50 Global Risks, 5 Categories, 5 Major Crises, 3 Major Risk Cases Berto Jongman: Deena Metzger– Seeing through Indigenous Eyes, Weaving Community Dreams, Stories and Spirit Berto Jongman: Humanitarian Aid & Forgotten Conflicts Berto Jongman: “Infrastructures for Peace” Berto Jongman: Recommended on Cultivating Peace Berto Jongman: Russian Sixth Generation Warfare and Role of Openness Berto Jongman: The Emerging Global Mind Berto Jongman: The Oracle of Belgrade – Early Warning Ignored Berto Jongman: Wikileaks, Open Data, Big Data, & Predicting Violence in Afghanistan Bojan Radej: Complex Society in the Radical Middle Breaking News: The Shift Hits the Fan Bruce Berkowitz: Failing to Keep Up With the Information Revolution The DI and “IT” Chuck Spinney: Grand Strategy Analysis of 9/11 Blow-Back Chuck Spinney: Reality Reporting from Syria — USG Has No Idea…. Chuck Spinney: The Mind of the Decider — Ignorance Plus Arrogance — Disconnected from Reality While All Others Buried Their Integrity CIA’s CTO Gus Hunt On Big Data: We ‘Try To Collect Everything And Hang Onto It Forever’ — And a Few Things Most CTOs Do Not Compute Citizen Intelligence on Food & Health Fraud Collective Impact: Alignment & Powerful Results CURVEBALL: The Interview + Integrity RECAP David Isenberg: Deep Web Research and Discovery Resources 2013 David Swanson: War and Being and Nothingness DefDog: Counter-IED Network Analysis – Works for Law Enforcement, Ignored by US Military DefDog: War Study – Troops Had Bad Intel, Worse Spin Definitions: M4IS2 (Multinational, Multiagency, Multidisciplinary, Multidomain Information-Sharing & Sense-Making Dignitarian & Transpartisan World Emerging? Diversity Magic–Breakthrough Possible Eagle: German View of America’s Decline – Five Step Healing Process Proposed by Robert Steele Event: 19 Nov Berlin, Interacting Minds–An Interdisciplinary Approach to Social Cognition Food speculation: ‘People die from hunger while banks make a killing on food’ FuturICT Living Earth Simulator; EarthGame / Whole Earth Strategic Analytic Model Gary North: Administrative Law (New World Order) versus Democracy (Live Free or Die) George Soros Nails It: Intelligence with Integrity GI Wilson: A Tale for the Day — US Government (the Titanic), National Security Spending (the Iceberg), and Why We Are Our Own Worst Enemy Government Archive on Public Intelligence (1992-2006) Harrison Owen: Public Administration in the 21st Century Highlights on the Democracy Front Historic Contributions Directory (List) History of Bureaucratic War on Public Intelligence (1992-2006) Intelligence with Integrity Chapter 1: Public Governance & Public Intelligence INTELLIGENCE with INTEGRITY: Preface 1.0 INTELLIGENCE with INTEGRITY Chapter 2: The InfoSphere & Its Enemies
INTELLIGENCE with INTEGRITY Chapter 3: The Human Factor INTELLIGENCE with INTEGRITY: Chapter 5 Systems Thinking & True Cost Economics INTERVIEW: Open Everything – with Robert David STEELE Vivas UPDATED to Add Parts V and VI INTERVIEW: PBS Frontline with Robert Steele on Hackers John Maguire: Jaron Lanier on How to Not Create a New Cyber Plutocracy John Maguire: YouTube (7:36) Cannabis Oil and the Post-Scarcity Era — Marijuana as Part of the Fiscal Solution AND Cures Cancer John Steiner: Laetus in Praesens – Convergence of 30 Disabling Global Trends John Taylor Gatto: The Ultimate History Lessons (1 Hour) Jon Lebkowsky: Collaboration, Cooperation, Democracy Journal: 21 Years Late, An Inkling of Discovery Journal: Anthropology 101–Not Being Listened To Journal: Cyber-Security Etc. & Multinational Engagement Journal: Design Thinking for Government Journal: Education and the Republic Journal: From Social “Science” HTT to KR Death Squads Journal: Human Terrain Team (HTT) Project Now Dabbling in Propaganda Journal: Mathematicians Get it Wrong…Again Journal: Multinational Transformation Journal: Tom Atlee Comments on Great Transition Journal: United Nations and Information-Sharing M4IS2 Manifesto for Open Research Marcus Aurelius: CINCSOC Doing the Right Thing for the Right Reasons Marcus Aurelius: Jennifer Sims Party Line on Military Clandestine Service with Robert Steele Comment + RECAP Marcus Aurelius: Letter from Joint Chiefs to Senate Armed Service Committee — Comment by Robert Steele + DoD Transformation RECAP Marcus Aurelius: Max Boot on Better Spies, Not More Marcus Aurelius: White House Flushing US Hawks on Iran — Meanwhile, Intelligence with Integrity About Iran is Completely Lacking Memorandum: OSS CEO to DNI One-Pager Michel Bauwens: Creating Sustainable Currencies with Open Source Software – No Printing, No Banks, No Government Abuses… Michel Bauwens: Rebirth of the Guilds Michel Bauwens: Rob Van Kranenburg on The Sensing Planet – Challenge is NOT Technology, Challenge is Ensuring Process is Inclusive and Open Michel Bauwens: The New Rules of Innovation – Bottom-Up Solutions to Top-Down Problems Michel Basuwens: The Relational State – The Human Factor Michel Bauwens: The Third Wave: Peer-to-Peer Immaterial Expansion MILITARY INTELLIGENCE: All Eyes No Brain Part II Mini-Me: Cuba-Venezuela Unite the South – CELAC Mini-Me: NATO Admiral Says the Future of Global Security is Strategic Communication — Robert Steele Corrects + META-RECAP Multidimensional Poverty Index (new) My Talk With Tom Atlee: Primer on Citizen Intelligence NATO OSINT to OSE/M4IS2 Round-Up Neal Rauhauser: Individual Reputation Metrics, Long Term Implications Network Learning to Team/Autonomous Learning NIGHTWATCH: From 1979 to 2012 – No Improvement in DoD Response to Ambassadors and Embassies in Extremis + EE21 RECAP Open Source Everything Manifesto: Extracts OPEN THE DOOR–Empower Not Power Owl: Why the Elite Would Lose a Civil War Parag Khanna and Frank Jacobs: The New World – More Small Nations, New Economic Zones, High-Speed Rail, Singapore to Vladivostok to London — While the Americas Decline Participatory Budgeting Practices, Games, Resources Patrick Meier: Jointly: Peer-to-Peer Disaster Recovery App Patrick Meier: Trails of Digital Trustworthness Patrick Meier: Twitter, Early Warning, Small Data Matters More Paul Fernhout: Open Letter to the Intelligence Advanced Programs Research Agency (IARPA) Penguin: Cataloging Wounds of War to Help Heal Them — Not Big Data, Not Small Data, But Rather Integrated “Smart” Data Perry Bezanis: Reflections on the Human Condition Policy Archives on Public Intelligence (1992-2006) Reference: A World That Works for All Reference: Building a National Information Strategy (India, 2002) Reference: Citizenship Versus Transpartisanship Reference: Cutting the Defense Budget + RECAP Reference: Evolution of the Apocalypse–Empire’s Demise, Human Renaissance by Carol Brouillet Reference: Expectations of Intelligence in the Information Age, Review by Steele, Wright, Anon & New Link 3.0 Reference: Frog 6 Guidance 2010-2020 Reference: Gorgon Stare–USAF Goes Nuts (Again) Reference: Human Intelligence (HUMINT) – All Humans, All Minds, All the Time [Full Text Online for Google Translate] Reference: Infinite Wealth for All Reference: Integrity–Without it Nothing Works II Reference: Interagency Conflict Assessment Framework (ICAF) Reference: Mobile Learning Displaces Distance Learning, Offers Hope for Five Billion Poor Reference: Open-Ended Semiosis – Symbiotic Intelligence Reference: Our Choice–Changing the Game Reference: Re-Inventing Fire Reference: Russell Ackoff on Doing Right Things Righter Reference: Science 2.0 by Ben Shneiderman Reference: The Privatization [Corruption] of Democracy – Honoring & Documenting the Work of Eva Waskell Reference: Transparency Killer App Plus “Open Everything” RECAP (Back to 01/2007) Reference: WATER–Soul of the Earth, Mirror of Our Collective Souls Reference: What Is the One Thing? On Democracy Reference: World Brain Institute & Global Game Reference: World Development Reform 2011 – Conflict, Security, & Development Reform Coalition: “True Cost” Economics & Genuine Progress + True Cost RECAP Regional Metamorphosis & Social Architecture Review (Fiction): Truce – The Day the World Was Perfect Review (DVD): The Fog of War – Eleven Lessons from the Life of Robert S. McNamara Review (Guest): 1993 Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology Review (Guest): Cognitive Surplus–Creativity and Generosity in a Connected Age Review (Guest): The Psychopath Test — A Journey Through the Madness Industry Review (Guest): The Wealth of the Commons: A World Beyond Market and State Review (Guest): Westmoreland – The General Who Lost Vietnam – Includes Second Review With Contextual Detail on Failure of Intelligence (Including Soviets Owning US Crypto) Review (Guest): Whole Earth Discipline Review: A Crowd of One–The Future of Individual Identity Review: A Democratic Approach to Sustainable Futures — A Workbook for Addressing the Global Problematique Review: Born To Learn: Unschooling In the New Paradigm Review: Charm Offensive–How China’s Soft Power Is Transforming the World Review: Collapse–How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed Review: Conscious Evolution: Awakening Our Social Potential Review: Corruption and Anti-Corruption–An Applied Philosophical Approach Review: Cultures and Globalization–Conflicts and Tensions (The Cultures and Globalization Series) (v. 1) Review: Edutopia–Success Stories for Learning in the Digital Age Review: Escaping the Matrix–How We the People can change the world Review: Evolutionary Dynamics–Exploring the Equations of Life Review: Fighting Identity–Sacred War and World Change (The Changing Face of War) Review: Finding Our Way–Leadership for an Uncertain Time (Hardcover) Review: For the Common Good–Redirecting the Economy toward Community, the Environment, and a Sustainable Future Review: Gag Rule–On the Suppression of Dissent and Stifling of Democracy Review: GIS for Decision Support and Public Policy Making Review: Global Public Policy – Governing Without Government? Review: Global Shift–How A New Worldview Is Transforming Humanity Review: Holistic Darwinism: Synergy, Cybernetics, and the Bioeconomics of Evolution Review: How People Harness Their Collective Wisdom and Power to Construct the Future Review: How to Run the World–Charting a Course to the Next Renaissance Review: IDENTITY ECONOMICS–How our Identities Shape Our Work, Wages, and Well-Being Review: Illicit–How Smugglers, Traffickers and Copycats are Hijacking the Global Economy (Hardcover) Review: Information Payoff–The Transformation of Work in the Electronic Age Review: Intelligent Governance for the 21st Century: A Middle Way between West and East Review: Internet-Based Intelligence in Public Health Emergencies – Early Detection and Response in Disease Outbreak Crises Review: Introduction to Paradigms–Overview, Definitions, Categories, Basics, Optimizing Paradigms & Paradigm Engines Review: Lines of Fire – A Renegade Writes on Strategy, Intelligence, and Security Review: Long Strange Journey–An Intelligence Memoir Review: Manifesto for the Noosphere: The Next Stage in the Evolution of Human Consciousness Review: Mobilizing Minds–Creating Wealth From Talent in the 21st Century Organization Review: Modern Strategy Review: National Security Dilemmas–Challenges and Opportunities Review: One from Many–VISA and the Rise of Chaordic Organization Review: Open Source Intelligence in a Networked World Review: Panarchy–Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems Review: Pedagogy of Freedom–Ethics, Democracy, and Civic Courage Review: Pedagogy of the Oppressed Review: Polarity Management – Identifying and Managing Unsolvable Problems Review: Resilience and the Behavior of Large-Scale Systems Review: Responsible History Review: Resource Wars–The New Landscape of Global Conflict Review: Saucers, Swastikas and Psyops: A History of A Breakaway Civilization: Hidden Aerospace Technologies and Psychological Operations Review: Seeing What’s Next–Using Theories of Innovation to Predict Industry Change Review: Social Change 2.0–A Blueprint for Reinventing Our World Review: State of the Unions–How Labor Can Strengthen the Middle Class, Improve Our Economy, and Regain Political Influence Review: Strategy–The Logic of War and Peace, Revised and Enlarged Edition Review: Surrender to Kindness (One Man’s Epic Journey for Love and Peace) Review: Technological Change and the Future of Warfare Review: The Blue Death–Disease, Disaster, and the Water We Drink Review: The Celestine Prophecy Review: The Collapse of Complex Societies Review: The Compassionate Instinct–The Science of Human Goodness Review: The Design of Business–Why Design Thinking is the Next Competitive Advantage Review: The Great Turning–From Empire to Earth Community Review: The Handbook of Large Group Methods–Creating Systemic Change in Organizations and Communities Review: The Human Factor–Inside the CIA’s Dysfunctional Intelligence Culture Review: The Information Diet – A Case for Conscious Consumption Review: The Ingenuity Gap–Facing the Economic, Environmental, and Other Challenges of an Increasingly Complex and Unpredictable Future Review: The leadership of civilization building–Administrative and civilization theory, symbolic dialogue, and citizen skills for the 21st century Review: The Lucifer Principle–A Scientific Expedition into the Forces of History (Paperback) Review: The Monk and the Riddle–The Art of Creating a Life While Making a Living Review: The Power of Unreasonable People–How Social Entrepreneurs Create Markets That Change the World Review: The Practice of Peace Review: The Principles of Representative Government Review: The Quest For Viable Peace–International Intervention And Strategies For Conflict Transformation (Paperback) Review: The Second Self–Computers and the Human Spirit Review: The World Is Open–How Web Technology Is Revolutionizing Education Review: Threshold–The Crisis of Western Culture Review: Unspeakable Truths–Facing the Challenges of Truth Commissions (Paperback) Review: Valuing the Earth–Economics, Ecology, Ethics Review: Warfare in the Third World Review: Water–The Epic Struggle for Wealth, Power, and Civilization Review: Water–The Fate of Our Most Precious Resource Review: What Comes After Money? Review: World 3.0 – Global Prosperity and How to Achieve It Review: World Population and Human Values–A New Reality REVOLUTION 2.0 CLOSED 17 May 2011 Richard Wright: It’s Only Money – Why the IC Continues to Fail & Robert Steele: 10% Grade – A Dishonorable Discharge Needed Richard Wright: On DoD Transformation, Chuck Hagel, & Zionist Meddling Richard Wright: Proposal for an Open Source Agency Richard Wright: Secret Intelligence Cloud, Charlie Allen’s Warning, Comment by Robert Steele Robert Steele: How Dutch Intelligence Survived & Prospered Using Open Source Human Intelligence as a Foundation for Ethical Evidence-Based Decisions Robert Steele: How Obama’s Team Melded Big Data to Raise Money & Win Votes, Defeating the “Nine Ways” and “Twelve Amigos” Robert Steele: On the Record – 4% of the Force Takes 80% of the Casualties, Receives 1% of the Pentagon Budget Robert Steele: World Brain / Global Game Update with Concept for School of Future-Oriented Hybrid Governance and Centre for Multinational Multiagency Multidisciplinary Multidomain Information-Sharing and Sense-Making (M4IS2) SchwartzReport: Tom Engelhardt — No Longer in Search of Enemies — We Have Created Them and Turned the World Against the USA Search (3): Analytic Models, 10 Threats, Threat Support to Acquisition Search (3): j2 africom; knowledge management graphics; dod spagetti Search (2): jongman world conflict map 1997 – jongman world conflict and human rights Search: carkhuff cleveland information technolog Search: cost of corruption + Corruption RECAP Search: develop intelligence through civil affairs Search: future of osint Search: how much humint is clandestine — Response by Robert Steele + Clandestine Meta-RECAP Search: humint [as of 20130127] Search: open education / digital learning [as of 30 Oct 2012] Search: OSC M4IS2 Search: smart nation intelligence reform electoral reform national security reform Search: Strategic Analytic Model Search: tactical versus strategic intelligence + Meta-RECAP Search: what is human truth Sepp Hasslberger: Scientists, Citizens, & Real-Time Pervasive Science Seth Godin: Back to (the wrong) school — inspires a plan to retrain 44% of the US workforce in one year SOCIAL SYSTEMS AND TRANSFORMATIONAL CHANGE Stephen Marrin: Evaluating the Quality of Intelligence Analysis: By What (Mis) Measure? With Comment by Robert Steele Steven Aftergood: Top Secret America–Totally Dysfunctional Steve Wheeler: Learning with ‘e’s – Education funnels and webs of learning Stuart Umpleby: Limitations of Hand-Held Dashboards + Cyber-Brain RECAP Theophillis Goodyear: Internet, Undersea Cables, Africa, and Digital Remittances Theophilis Goodyear: Panarchy versus Anarchy – Non-Hierarchal, Network-Controled Governance + Panarchy RECAP Thomas Briggs: Comments on the US Secret Super Cloud — Dead Since 1995 — With Two Thoughts from Robert Steele Thomas Briggs: Reflections on OSINT in Support of HUMINT Tom Atlee: Big Breakthrough in Group Process Tom Atlee: Citizen Wisdom Councils – OUR Treasure Tom Atlee: Collective Thinking About Public Affairs Tom Atlee: Diversity Matters Tom Atlee: Empowering Public Wisdom – A Practical Vision of Citizen-Led Politics Top Atlee: Final Words from Ernest Callenbach the Author of Ecotopia & Ecotopia Emerging Tom Atlee: Occupy Adopts Open Everything Meme Tom Atlee: Participatory Wisdom & Sustainability Tom Atlee: Reflections on Consensus — from Ugly to Beautiful Tom Atlee: Seeking Leverage for Deep Transformation Tom Atlee: Six Faces of Wholeness Tom Atlee: Vibrant, effective responses to disaster? YES! say two remarkable women… Tom Atlee: Wisdom of the Fringes? Transformational Pivot in the Internet’s Nature Turkey to USA: This is where you get off….+ RECAP USA Has Become Deaf, Dumb, and Blind Vatican, Ethics, & Truth II (Full Text Online for Google Translate) Venessa Miemis: Birth of a Meme – The Rise of Culture Tech Venessa Miemis: Critical Need for Self-Care When World-Building Venessa Miemis: Mary Meeker on 12 Internet Trends Way of the Truth Winslow Wheeler: Marine Corps and the F-35 — Outright Lies, Deception, and a Total Lack of Intelligence with Integrity Worth a Look: Air University on Future Studies Worth A Look: A View from the Emergence Edge Worth a Look: Beyond Intractability – Online Learning At Its Best Worth a Look: Books on Ethics and Democracy Worth a Look: Book Reviews on Democracy Lost & Found Worth a Look: Book Reviews on Evolutionary Dynamics Worth a Look: Book Reviews on General & Specific Corruption 2.0 Worth a Look: Book Reviews on Intelligence (Most) Worth a Look: Book Reviews on Peace Worth a Look: Book Reviews on Technology & Web 2.0 to 4.0 Worth a Look: CSSC – Centre for Science, Society and Citizenship Worth a Look: Human Transformation Welcome Message (Organizational Version) Worth a Look: Innovation Orientation Worth a Look: Institute for 21st Century Agoras Worth a Look: Open Farm Technology Worth a Look: Sign-Up Today to Be Part of Human Transformation Project Worth a Look: The Anti-Globalization Breakfast Club: Manifesto for a Peaceful Revolution Worth a Look: Transformation Through Education & Training–NATO’s Emergent Approach Yoda: $16 Trillion Or So – Opportunity Costs & Integrity Lost Yoda: Child-Driven Education, Convergence of Knowledge Yoda: Peter Skillen on Scaffolding for Deep (Collaborative) Understanding