Review (Guest): SALVAGING AMERICAN DEFENSE–The Challenge of Strategic Overstretch

5 Star, Budget Process & Politics, Economics, Force Structure (Military), Iraq, Military & Pentagon Power, Power (Pathologies & Utilization), Public Administration, Security (Including Immigration), Stabilization & Reconstruction, Strategy, War & Face of Battle
Amazon Page

Anthony H. Cordesman; with Paul S. Frederiksen and William D. Sullivan (Author)

5.0 out of 5 stars Real Defense Exertise, December 22, 2010

Anthony Cordesman is by any rational measure an expert in defense, security, and intelligence issues. Virtually his entire career has been devoted to the study and analysis of these issues, yet he would probably be the first to note that he has also never stopped learning new things about all of them. All this is by way saying that this 2007 book that he authored is well worth reading and pondering.

Cordesman argues that the entire U.S. Department of Defense (DOD) is dysfunctional to such an extent that U.S. security is at risk. He documents his claim in 11 chapters organized as `challenges’ to be over come. His central theme, however, and one that is revisited in almost every chapter is that for too long the civilian and military leadership of DOD has failed to link strategy, force plans, programs, and budget. Rather, these core DOD processes are each executed in a vacuum. Strategic goals do not inform organizational structuring of military forces or military design and procurement programs. The procurement programs in turn are not informed by either proposed or actual military force structure or operational doctrines. Strategy, force plans, and programs are not reflected in accurately in budget formulation. The Joint Chiefs of Staff (JCS) appears to be incapable of integrating these processes. DOD civilian management has equally failed to integrate these core processes. This across the board failure of leadership has been most clearly demonstrated in the congressionally mandated Quadrennial Defense Review (QDR) that should have uncovered this lack of integration and argued for tying the budget formulation process directly to the design of force structures and programs designed to equip those structures. Instead the QDRs have steadily declined in quality to the point that the 2010 QDR was so badly formulated as to be palpably worthless.

Cordesman has done a good job in documenting the problems within DOD and has buttressed his argument with numerous charts and graphs. Still this book is a rather dry read although it is a very important analysis of the flawed processes by which DOD is trying manage the defense of America. It should also be noted that Cordesman and his two co-authors do not work for the government. Cordesman holds the Chair for Strategy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), a widely respected Washington think tank. CSIS published this study.

Vote and/or Comment on Review

See Also:

Reference: Anthony Cordesman On Intelligence

Review: The Conservative Soul–How We Lost It, How to Get It Back

5 Star, Congress (Failure, Reform), Democracy, Empire, Sorrows, Hubris, Blowback, Executive (Partisan Failure, Reform), Philosophy, Politics, Religion & Politics of Religion

Amazon Page
Amazon Page

Philosophical, Practical, Gifted Turns of Phrase, Starting Point,

November 8, 2006
Andrew Sullivan
This is a philosophical essay, not a political diatribe. This is a very educated, articulate, thoughtful, and practical book. It is so good it probably needs to be read more than once.

As an estranged moderate Republican who believes in a balanced budget, smaller government, and minimalist interference in state, local, and individual rights not assigned to the federal government by the Constitution (and also the elimination of central banks that are NOT authorized by the Constitution), I found provocation, solace, and humor in this book (the discussion of the role of the penis and its eternal sperm, in relation to fundamentalist strictures and fears, is alone worth the price of the book).

Gifted turns of phrases as well as erudite references to both ancient and modern philosopher-kings abound. I especially likes “Immoral decisions, in other words, are like environmental pollutants” (page 125), and on page 209, “In this nonfundamentalists understanding of faith, practice is more imporant than theory, love more important than law, and mystery is seen as an insight into truth rather than an obstacle.”

The author’s real life as a gay man who has survived AIDS no doubt infuriates the fundamentalists and the less hypocritical evangelists, but this is part and parcel of his qualifications–he completely trashes both the incumbent President and the Christian extremist fundamentalists that have substituted dogma for dialog.

This is a personal essay. It is neither a summary nor a substitute for the many other books I have reviewed on both the left and the right, and so I end by saying that the book gets five stars for its extra leavening of philosophical reasoning, but I urge those who find favor in this book to throw a wider net, or at least read my reviews of the last 25 books on ideology, religion, faith, Iraq, and the impeachable offenses of Bush-Cheney.

Vote on Review
Vote on Review

Click Here to Vote on Review at Amazon,

on Cover Above to Buy or Read Other Reviews,

I Respond to Comments Here or There

Commerce Archive on Public Intelligence (1992-2006)

Commerce
Archive 1992-2006
Archive 1992-2006

2004

SE

CommerceBjoreCommercial Intelligence

2003

SE

CommerceBjoreReinventing Commercial Intelligence

2002

US

CommerceKlavansIdentifying Commercial Opportunities from Emerging Science

2000

US

CommerceTechnology Intelligence from Patents

2000

US

CommerceSullivanBusiness Perspective on Essential Overseas Information

1999

FR

CommerceBaumlinEspionage or Business Intelligence: Nuances of Gray

1999

UK

CommerceCollierOverview of New Horizons in OSINT Sources, Softwares, Services

1999

US

CommerceMillerThe Year the Information Industry Hit Bottom

1999

US

CommerceRobinsonHow Mobil Uses Open Sources & Services

1998

FR

CommerceBaumlinBlack, White, Gray, Realities of the Investigative Marketplace

1998

US

CommerceBoyerAssessing US and Other Space Imaging Options for European Needs

1998

GE

CommerceBrucknerInformation and Knowledge Management in Intelligence Situations

1998

US

CommerceBurwellCommercial Online Source Validation Methods

1998

UK

CommerceCollierThe Pricing of Electronic Information

1998

US

CommerceDunnConfronting the Future of the Information Industry

1998

Israel

CommerceFeilerOpen and Personal: Economic Intelligence in the Middle East

1998

US

CommerceHorowitzEconomic Espionage and OSINT: Legal and Security Implications

1998

US

CommerceStaraValuing Competitive Intelligence

1998

US

CommerceYankeelovPushing the Assets of Time and Knowledge

1997

BE

CommerceBorry & SohlElectronic Sources & Methods: A Belgian Business Perspective

1997

US

CommerceSuggsInternational Trade & Commerce Intelligence Search Strategies (Slides)

1997

US

CommerceSuggsInternational Trade & Commerce Intelligence Search Strategies (Text)

1996

US

CommerceBatesRecent and Emerging Trends in Information Brokering

1996

US

CommerceCallRealities & Myths Regarding Financial Research Using Open Sources

1996

US

CommerceKolb (SCIP)Sales Pitch for the Society of Competitive Intelligence Professionals

1996

US

CommerceSibbitEmerging Business Models for Commercial Remote Sensing

1996

US

CommerceSteeleConcise Directory of Selected International Open Sources & Services

1996

US

CommerceSteeleOpen Source Intelligence Handbook, Chapter 1, Overview

1995

US

CommerceHerringBusiness Intelligence in Japan and Sweden: Lessons for the US

1995

US

CommerceHerringIntelligence to Enhance American Companies’ Competitiveness

1995

US

CommerceHerringUsing the Intelligence Process to Create Competitive Global Advantage

1995

US

CommerceSimon & BlixtEmerging Issues in Competitive Intelligence

1994

US

CommerceBaschSecrets of the Super-Searchers: A Personal and Practical Perspective

1994

Switz

CommerceBernhardtTailoring Competitive Intelligence to Executive Needs

1994

UK

CommerceCollierGlobal Information Industry and a New Information Paradigm

1994

US

CommerceHimelfarbIntroduction to Competitive and Business Intelligence

1994

US

CommerceKellyASIDIC Perspectives & Its Contributions to National Competitiveness (S)

1994

US

CommerceKellyASIDIC Perspectives & Its Contributions to National Competitiveness (T)

1994

US

CommerceMarcinkoAssociation of Information and Dissemination Centers, Case Studies

1994

US

CommerceShakerBeating the Competition: From Boardroom to War Room

1994

US

CommerceShaker & RiceFrom War Room to Board Room

1994

US

CommerceSharpHow to Identify Changes that Threaten Your Business Activity, In Advance

1994

US

CommerceStanatThe Power of Global Business Information

1994

US

CommerceSteeleGermany: ACCESS:  Theory and Practice of Competitor Intelligence

1994?

US

CommerceSteeleASIDIC: Intelligence Community as a New Market

1993

US

CommerceCaldwellInternational Investigative Market (Slides)

1993

US

CommerceCaldwellInternational Investigative Market (Text)

1993

SE

CommerceDedijerEurope’s To BI or not to BE: Inventory of a New Business Innovation

1993

US

CommerceEliasAn Overview of the Information Industry in 1993

1993

AU

CommerceFraumannBusiness is War

1993

US

CommerceHerringBusiness Intelligence: Some Have It, Some Don’t–How They Do It

1993

US

CommerceHimelfarbIntelligence Requirements for Executives

1993

US

CommerceMonaco & GerliczyEconomic Intelligence and Open Source Information

1993

JP

CommerceShimaOverview of Japanese Media and Information Systems

1993

US

CommerceSplittThe U.S. Information Industry: Changing the 21st Century

1993

US

CommerceSteeleCorporate Role in National Competitiveness

1993

US

CommerceSteeleThe Intelligence Community as a New Market

1992

US

CommerceHlavaInformation Industry Corporations (Partial Listing)

1992

US

CommerceHlavaSelected Professional and Trade Associations in Information

1992

US

CommerceHlavaThe Information Industry: Impact of Globalization

1992

US

CommerceMeyerBusiness Intelligence at the Cutting Edge

1992

US

CommerceNobelFrom A to Z: What We’ve Done with Open Sources

1992

US

CommerceShaker & KarduliasIntelligence Support to U.S. Business

1992

US

CommerceWilliamsOSINT to Create Intelligence in a Commercial Environment